Osama bin Laden is quite probably the most hated and vilified figure in the American consciousness. And rightly so.
The man has said that he wants to destroy the America’s global economic dominance. Today he took aim at the United States’ failure to curb carbon emissions.
To stop global warming, he called for the “wheels of the American economy” to be brought to a halt. “This is possible … if the peoples of the world stop consuming American goods.”
First off, even if the American economy came to a halt, emissions would still rise, global consumption would rise and the US would be deprived of its capacity to transition to clean energy. If he really wanted to help the “tens of millions [driven] into poverty and unemployment” he would not seek to tear down the markets required to produce clean energy. Access to reliable energy is directly associated with raising living standards. Unless bin Laden wants the world’s population to continue using fossil fuels, he must recognize the need for clean energy development, which requires investment and robust markets.
I have to conclude that his strategy is not to stop global warming, but rather to draw broader global support for his anti-American efforts. What better way to wreak havoc and chaos in the nation of his enemies than to associate himself with one of the fastest growing sectors of the US economy: clean energy.
After all, bin Laden is the new Hitler. Folks throw his name around when they want to paint something or someone as un-patriotic, irrational or evil. By highlighting the climate challenge, bin Laden opens the floodgates for climate deniers to claim that taking action on climate issues is now un-American, anti-American and that seeks to destroy the economy.
These claims of course are untrue, offensive and unacceptable.
But they sure as hell create yet another barrier to developing a clean energy economy (added to fossil fuel interests entrenched in Congress, a tough investment environment and the infuriatingly slow pace of climate negotiation).
So while yes, the US has shirked its responsibility to tackle climate change, I cannot see how bin Laden’s call to action actually advances this goal. Instead, Osama bin Laden just handed the enemies of clean energy a grenade launcher, which they eagerly received.
